Skip to content
FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $65+

Murder Mystery Party: Underwood Cellars - Puzzle Mystery Board Game for Family and Adults (1+ Players, Age 14+) - University Games

4.85 (135)
Store-Wide Rating

Murder Mystery Party: Underwood Cellars - Puzzle Mystery Board Game for Family and Adults (1+ Players, Age 14+) - University Games

$26.99
Original price $26.99 - Original price $26.99
Original price
$26.99 - $26.99
Current price $26.99
Age 14+
New
Quantity:

Availability:

Only   6 left in stock   - order soon!

DELIVERY

Order today for delivery July 18 to July 26

GUARANTEED SAFE CHECKOUT

Free truck icon
Free truck icon

Free Shipping on Orders Over $65

Other delivery options are available, which you can choose during checkout

Free truck icon

Proudly Shipped from a Small Family-Owned Business in Wisconsin, USA

We ship all your orders from a small town in Wisconsin from our small family owned and operated business. When you shop with Poggers, you're supporting a small business, not a mega corporation!

Free truck icon

30-Day Free Returns

We hope that your order arrives to your satisfaction, but in case it doesn't, we will be happy to give you a pre-paid return label so you can return it for a full refund! There are no risks when ordering with Poggers!

Free truck icon

Product Information

Step into the shoes of a cold case detective and uncover secrets buried for decades in Murder Mystery Party: Underwood Cellars. The suspense begins the moment you open the file. Hidden beneath layers of time and silence lies a long-forgotten crime—now it’s up to you to finally solve it.

An earthquake has revealed chilling evidence from a mysterious disappearance 30 years ago. With the Underwood Cellars estate stirring with secrets, you’ll sift through letters, reports, and cryptic clues to uncover the truth. Whether working solo or collaborating with friends and family, every twist pulls you deeper into the web of deception.

If you're a fan of true crime stories or love testing your logic and deduction skills, this immersive mystery game is for you. Designed for one or more players aged 14 and up, it’s a perfect activity for cozy nights, family challenges, or group game nights. Are you ready to solve what others couldn’t?

Victim & Suspect Photos

Crime Scene Photos

Newspaper Articles

Other Case Evidence

Online Hints & Solutions

Protective Packaging

Manufacturer: University Games

Year Manufactured: 2022

Item Weight: 1.06 pounds

Item UPC: 023332332809

Budding detectives will love every minute of trying to solve the Underwood Cellars Case Files. This crime-busting game provides everything you need to try and solve the case! You have been given the Underwood Cellars Case Files but who did it? It has been 30 years since Cary Underwood disappeared. Due to a recent earthquake, we now have discovered the body and more clues to crack this case. Work alone or with others to deduce the victim’s murderer, their motive, their means, and the opportunity for the murder. Perfect as a single player or multiple player game, for players age 12 years and over.

University Games is a renowned creator and publisher of innovative board games, puzzles, and activities that have delighted audiences of all ages for decades. Established in 1985, the company has consistently prioritized creativity, fun, and education, offering a diverse array of products that cater to children, families, and adults. With a mission to inspire playful learning and meaningful connections, University Games has become a trusted name in the world of games. Its product lines range from educational series like I Spy and Pete the Cat for younger players to exciting party games for adults. Each game is designed to foster imagination, critical thinking, and entertainment, ensuring hours of enjoyment.

In addition to its expansive catalog, University Games is committed to innovation and high-quality craftsmanship. The company continually introduces fresh ideas to the market, embracing themes that engage modern audiences while preserving timeless appeal. From hands-on activities like Doodletop under the U-Create brand to strategic and imaginative games from the Forbidden Games collection, University Games offers something for everyone. With a presence in homes worldwide, the company remains dedicated to enhancing social interaction, sparking creativity, and creating lasting memories for families and friends.



product-benefitsCold case mystery with immersive storytelling and layered clues: Dive into a suspenseful crime narrative set 30 years in the past, waiting for fresh eyes to uncover the truth.

product-benefitsSolo or group play for flexible game night options: Enjoy an engaging puzzle experience alone or work together with others to crack the mystery through collaboration.

product-benefitsDetailed evidence including documents and physical clues: Examine realistic case materials that replicate what an actual investigator might use to solve a murder mystery.

product-benefitsCrime-solving gameplay focused on motive, method, and opportunity: Players must analyze information and make deductions to determine who committed the crime and why.

product-benefitsGreat for fans of detective stories and puzzle-solving games: Appeals to sleuths and strategists who love exploring complex scenarios and solving challenging mysteries.

product-benefitsNo time limit or app required for uninterrupted play: Designed to let players think at their own pace without digital distractions or countdown pressures.

product-benefitsIdeal for ages 14+ with content suitable for teens and adults: Thematic elements are crafted for mature players while avoiding anything too graphic or dark.

product-benefitsPerfect as a gift or party game for mystery lovers: Makes a unique and thoughtful present for fans of thrillers, crime fiction, or immersive board games.

Poggers Product Information

Product Information

Product Description

expand

Step into the shoes of a cold case detective and uncover secrets buried for decades in Murder Mystery Party: Underwood Cellars. The suspense begins the moment you open the file. Hidden beneath layers of time and silence lies a long-forgotten crime—now it’s up to you to finally solve it.

An earthquake has revealed chilling evidence from a mysterious disappearance 30 years ago. With the Underwood Cellars estate stirring with secrets, you’ll sift through letters, reports, and cryptic clues to uncover the truth. Whether working solo or collaborating with friends and family, every twist pulls you deeper into the web of deception.

If you're a fan of true crime stories or love testing your logic and deduction skills, this immersive mystery game is for you. Designed for one or more players aged 14 and up, it’s a perfect activity for cozy nights, family challenges, or group game nights. Are you ready to solve what others couldn’t?

Manufacturer Description

expand

Budding detectives will love every minute of trying to solve the Underwood Cellars Case Files. This crime-busting game provides everything you need to try and solve the case! You have been given the Underwood Cellars Case Files but who did it? It has been 30 years since Cary Underwood disappeared. Due to a recent earthquake, we now have discovered the body and more clues to crack this case. Work alone or with others to deduce the victim’s murderer, their motive, their means, and the opportunity for the murder. Perfect as a single player or multiple player game, for players age 12 years and over.

Product Specifics

expand

Manufacturer: University Games

Year Manufacturered : 2022

Item Weight: 1.06 pounds

Item UPC: 023332332809

Box Contents

expand

Victim & Suspect Photos

Crime Scene Photos

Newspaper Articles

Other Case Evidence

Online Hints & Solutions

Protective Packaging

About University Games

expand

University Games is a renowned creator and publisher of innovative board games, puzzles, and activities that have delighted audiences of all ages for decades. Established in 1985, the company has consistently prioritized creativity, fun, and education, offering a diverse array of products that cater to children, families, and adults. With a mission to inspire playful learning and meaningful connections, University Games has become a trusted name in the world of games. Its product lines range from educational series like I Spy and Pete the Cat for younger players to exciting party games for adults. Each game is designed to foster imagination, critical thinking, and entertainment, ensuring hours of enjoyment.

In addition to its expansive catalog, University Games is committed to innovation and high-quality craftsmanship. The company continually introduces fresh ideas to the market, embracing themes that engage modern audiences while preserving timeless appeal. From hands-on activities like Doodletop under the U-Create brand to strategic and imaginative games from the Forbidden Games collection, University Games offers something for everyone. With a presence in homes worldwide, the company remains dedicated to enhancing social interaction, sparking creativity, and creating lasting memories for families and friends.



product-benefits Cold case mystery with immersive storytelling and layered clues: Dive into a suspenseful crime narrative set 30 years in the past, waiting for fresh eyes to uncover the truth.

product-benefits Solo or group play for flexible game night options: Enjoy an engaging puzzle experience alone or work together with others to crack the mystery through collaboration.

product-benefits Detailed evidence including documents and physical clues: Examine realistic case materials that replicate what an actual investigator might use to solve a murder mystery.

product-benefits Crime-solving gameplay focused on motive, method, and opportunity: Players must analyze information and make deductions to determine who committed the crime and why.

product-benefits Great for fans of detective stories and puzzle-solving games: Appeals to sleuths and strategists who love exploring complex scenarios and solving challenging mysteries.

product-benefits No time limit or app required for uninterrupted play: Designed to let players think at their own pace without digital distractions or countdown pressures.

product-benefits Ideal for ages 14+ with content suitable for teens and adults: Thematic elements are crafted for mature players while avoiding anything too graphic or dark.

product-benefits Perfect as a gift or party game for mystery lovers: Makes a unique and thoughtful present for fans of thrillers, crime fiction, or immersive board games.

Murder Mystery Party: Underwood Cellars - Puzzle Mystery Board Game for Family and Adults (1+ Players, Age 14+) - University Games
$26.99
4.85 (135)
Store-Wide Rating

Availability:

Only   6 left in stock   - order soon!

Order today for delivery July 18 to July 26
4.85 ( 135 )
Store-Wide Rating

GUARANTEED SAFE CHECKOUT

Related Products

Any Questions? Look Here

If you need more help, send us an email at hello@poggers.com or call us at our warehouse (262-476-5047) on Monday through Friday, from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. CST and we'll help you out!

Poggers Frequently Asked Questions

We fulfill orders as quickly as possible when we're at the Poggers warehouse, Monday through Friday, from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. CST—usually within 24 hours of receiving your order. If you place an order over the weekend, it will be fulfilled that following Monday. We aim to hand the package to the shipping carrier within 24 hours, but depending on when the order was placed and how busy we are (we're a small family business, after all), it may take up to 48 hours to get it into the carrier's hands.

The time it takes for your order to arrive depends on the shipping method you choose and when we fulfill the order, as explained above. Carriers typically have a 24-hour handling time before your package enters their system and they start counting the shipping days.

For example, if you select a 3-day shipping method on Monday, the carrier will likely receive it on Tuesday and won't begin counting the 3-day shipping until Wednesday, meaning you should expect it to arrive by Friday, Saturday, or possibly even the following Monday, depending on whether that carrier operates on weekends (e.g., UPS usually does not deliver on weekends). Due to the variability in shipping times, we strongly suggest placing your order as soon as possible if it's time-sensitive.

We're located in a small town of around 2,000 people named “Belgium” in the state of Wisconsin, USA. And no, it's not the country of Belgium—it's a tiny town called “Belgium” that you probably haven't heard of. There's not much going on here, but we do have a nice gas station that recently opened, where we usually get our morning coffees!

Poggers is the best toy store in the world, of course! Well, we might be a little biased... (probably). We're a small, family-owned and operated business with just a handful of employees working out of a 5,000 sq. ft. warehouse in the Midwest, USA. We sell all kinds of toys, games, collectibles, anime merchandise, and pretty much anything you’d want if you like having fun!

It's true that when you place an order, we make a couple of bucks, but instead of helping those super-rich shareholders of massive corporations get even richer, you can support us!

To be transparent, we're currently saving up to open our first brick-and-mortar location, so every order helps! We're trying to build a really cool and fun business, with (hopefully) a store that makes you say, “Wow, this place is cool!” when you walk in. The only way we can do that is with your support. So please help us out by clicking that “Add to Cart” button!

Customer Reviews

Be the first to write a review
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)

Reviews for Similar Products

Louie Hagopian's image

Awesome site!!

★★★★★ Louie Hagopian

Got my items really fast and they were in perfect condition. Will definitely order from here more since they have a great selection of stuff that’s hard to find on other sites. Thank you!! :)

Shane Wilson's image

I LOVE THIS WALLET !!

★★★★★ Shane Wilson

if you’re a lifelong Yu-Gi-Oh! fan such as myself, then this is the wallet for you. It’s beautiful and the quality is amazing. Thank you so much to the Poggers family for packing it so delicately and getting it to me quick ! all love & I am definitely ordering more !

Taber Long's image

Love it!

★★★★★ Taber Long

Fits exactly as I was hoping! I've struggled to find a hat that has a theme I like while not having a massive dome that makes it look huge when worn. Quality is superb. Also love being able to support a small business that appreciates their customers!

What Other People Say About Poggers

One big wholesome nerdy family.

Just a very fast, friendly, group that feels like a classic family owned toy shop.
Every step of the way, they made sure my package was sent, tracking data and even wanted to make sure it arrived. Like a friend wanting to make sure your present arrived on time.
When it arrived, there were surprises as well, which wasn't necessary, but made me smile.
I ordered a card game, but friends of mine have ordered figurines and plush toys and have had also a great experience.
The fact this was placed during Thanksgiving and during a rough weather storm in Wisconsin was equally amazing!I
love this group and recommend it, even if it's $2-3 more compared to Amazon and other Retailers, this is such a caring retailer.
Give it a try, the service stands out!

- Jordan H.

Best Apprehension Buy Ever!

I was slightly wary originally to purchase from this story because I'd never heard of it, and when it comes to figures I am extra worrisome but I took the chance because they had a Gojo figure I'd been searching for and couldn't find without it costing an arm and a leg.
The price was fair, so I gave them a chance and I'm happy I did because the figure came in original packaging and clearly unboxed.
It was pristine and exactly as pictured, and it came rather quickly I'd like to add.
The note attached to the invoice was super cute and made me smile. (Shout out to Ray, a fellow JJK fan.) I will certainly buy from here again in the future with no apprehension.
All I ask is that you get the JJK0 Geto noodle stopper figure soon!

- Chasedy H.

Absolutely Fantastic!

I was hesitant at first because I'd never heard of this store and they are quite new, but they're absolutely amazing! Professional and yet delightfully quirky with emails and update, and the site it's self is easy to navigate! They have stock that's old and new at very good yet legitimate prices, and seem to have a range of products from Hatsune Miku to Batman to Pokemon to Skyrim! Big store variety with little store charm, will be buying from them again for sure!!!

- Ginger H.

First time customer at Poggers

Great price for a Catan expansion! Skeptical at first because they had the lowest price on that item and I've never heard of the company before, so I did a quick google search for the reliability of the company and decided to give them a try.
They're very accommodating with request. Quick and fast response/service.
Item shipped out the next business day.
This is a legitimate family owned company so I'm definitely going to give them more of my business when needed.

- Phuong

Just placed my first purchase with POGGERS…

Just placed my first purchase with POGGERS! I found what I was looking for, had a good price & received it today in a very properly wrapped box.
I KNOW my grandson will love this. I believe I have found a GREAT toy store!!

- John Doe

AS FEATURED IN

The Wall Street Jaurnal
Today Featured
New York Post
Wisn ABC