Looking for the perfect gift for a Magic: The Gathering fan? I got you! Whether they’re deep into card collecting, strategizing with friends, or just love cool, game-inspired gear, there’s something here that’ll make their next game night even better.

From gear that helps protect prized cards to accessories that bring out the magic in everyday life, these picks will wow any MTG fan – new or seasoned. Get ready to find something that will make their deck – and their day – a bit more magical.

Best Magic: The Gathering Gifts Comparison Table

1. Magic: The Gathering – The Best Magic: The Gathering Blanket

Our Rating: 5/5 stars 

There’s nothing like a cozy Magic: The Gathering match, right? Sure, it might get heated and not be that cozy, but you know what I mean. This winter, though, you can enjoy some relaxed MTG time with friends, sipping hot cocoa while wrapped up in a warm blanket. And guess what? I have the perfect blanket for you.

Why We Like It

Not only does it have a scorching-hot design featuring one of Magic: The Gathering’s best dragons, but this 48 x 60-inch Magic: The Gathering blanket is also made of 100% polyester flannel, providing softness and warmth. Whether on your couch, gaming chair, or bed, it elevates both your comfort and your room’s style, making it one of the best gifts for Magic: The Gathering fans.

2. Magic: The Gathering – The Best Magic: The Gathering Mug

Our Rating: 5/5 stars

With the right company and cards, you’re all set for a fantastic time playing Magic: The Gathering for hours. However, anything that can enhance the vibe is absolutely welcome. One of those things? A beautiful MTG-themed mug that pairs well with any deck and adds a magical touch to your game. Lucky for you, you’ve just found that mug. Let me tell you about it.

Why We Like It

With a Magic: The Gathering-inspired brown design and a print of Nicol Bolas, there’s nothing I’d change about this mug. It doesn’t just look great; it’s sturdy and functional, too. Made from high-quality ceramic and holding up to 16 ounces of your favorite beverage, this is a Magic: The Gathering gift no fan could refuse.

3. Magic: The Gathering – The Best Magic: The Gathering Protective Card Sleeves

Our Rating: 5/5 stars

Every Magic player knows that keeping your favorite deck in top condition is key to the game. Sure, collecting and playing with the cards is amazing, but keeping them looking fresh is essential. That’s why I love protective sleeves, especially this Wrenn and Six one. It protects your cards and looks great – just like any Magic: The Gathering gift should.

Why We Like It

Made by Ultra PRO, a company known for durability and high-quality materials, these Magic: The Gathering card sleeves are a must-have accessory for all players. They hold up to 100 cards, keeping them safe from damage and in superb condition. Plus, with a design featuring the majestic Wrenn and Six, your collection will look fantastic. Practical and stylish – this is how you know this is one of the best Magic: The Gathering gifts.

4. Magic: The Gathering – The Best Magic: The Gathering Playmat

Our Rating: 4.5/5 stars 

For a full Magic experience, having all of the accessories can really improve how you enjoy the game. Yes, there is absolutely nothing wrong with playing on a regular table, but adding a little touch of MTG’s wonderful fantasy world can truly immerse you into each match. While I already gave you some Magic: The Gathering gift ideas to do this, I must not skip this amazing playmat. It’s a must-have in my opinion.

Why We Like It

With dimensions of 24 x 13 inches and durable yet soft material, this Magic: The Gathering playmat lets you enjoy your matches like never before. And, to back up its quality, it features a stunning Sword of Sinew and Steel design that takes things to the next level. Sounds super cool? It gets even better with a non-slip rubber backing that keeps everything stable. That said, you really can’t go wrong with this choice – it’s among the best Magic: The Gathering gifts and playmats for a reason.

5. Magic: The Gathering – The Best Magic: The Gathering Pin Badge

Our Rating: 4.5/5 stars 

Having the best MTG cards isn’t enough; sometimes, you want to carry them with you. To avoid damaging the real cards, here’s an awesome idea – a Magic: The Gathering card pin badge. Now, while some of you may or may not like Venser, Shaper Savant, we can all agree that it’s a strong card when played right. Plus, it looks fantastic, making this pin badge an excellent MTG gift choice.

Why We Like It

What I love most about this pin is that it’s based on Aleksi Briclot’s original artwork, staying true to its original colors with a blackout style that beautifully highlights the character’s appearance. Plus, you can interact with this Pinfinity MTG pin badge via the official app to play music, take a selfie, or download a phone wallpaper. Oh, and the text on the card changes, too. Pretty cool, I’d say.

6. Magic: The Gathering – The Best Magic: The Gathering Pocket Card Binder

Our Rating: 4.5/5 stars

Storing your Magic: The Gathering decks just anywhere should be illegal! Let’s be honest – not only does it look messy, but it doesn’t make sense. So, if you or a fellow fan still don’t own a deck box or a pocket card binder, you definitely need this one. It’s a must-have for anyone who loves the game and one of the best Magic: The Gathering gifts out there.

Why We Like It

First and foremost, the quality of this Magic: The Gathering pocket card binder is unmatched. Now, let’s talk functionality: with a secure zippered closure, it can hold up to 480 of your favorite standard-sized cards, organized in twelve acid-free, non-PVC pockets with four card playset rows. This way, you can carry your Magic: The Gathering collection anywhere with you, ensuring it’s always safe and ready for a match or trade.

7. Magic: The Gathering – The Best Magic: The Gathering Hat

Our Rating: 4.5/5 stars

Just as I can’t imagine going too long without playing Magic: The Gathering, I also can’t picture a casual outfit without a hat – especially on a sunny day. If you’re like me, you’ll definitely love this stylish Magic: The Gathering hat to elevate your look. And that’s not all! Just like the cards’ abilities, this hat has one of its own called “protection from the sun.”

Why We Like It

When searching for the best Magic: The Gathering gift, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed and unsure of what to get a fan. However, a black snapback hat featuring the MTG logo on the front and a print under the pre-curved bill is an amazing choice. Plus, it’s one-size-fits-all, so there’s no need to worry about sizing. Honestly, it’s a gift that any fan would love.

8. Magic: The Gathering – The Best Magic: The Gathering T-Shirt

Our Rating: 4.5/5 stars 

Is there a dress code for playing Magic: The Gathering? I haven’t heard of an official one, but you could always create one for your next game night. And before you do, may I suggest something? How about everyone wear this Magic: The Gathering T-shirt? It goes well with any outfit and will definitely add to the fun – even if you’re losing.

Why We Like It

There may not be a card that can boost your "style" stats, but that doesn’t mean you can’t still level up your look. With this Magic: The Gathering T-shirt featuring the Planeswalker symbol on the front, you’ll be doing just that – and by a lot of points! Style isn’t the only thing you’re gaining; this T-shirt is also super soft and durable. If this were an MTG card, I’d say it would be one of the strongest.

9. Magic: The Gathering – The Best Magic: The Gathering Water Bottle

Our Rating: 4/5 stars

Staying hydrated keeps your wit sharp and your mind ready for every Magic match. And that’s where this Magic: The Gathering water bottle comes in, helping you stay refreshed in style while also bringing that magical feeling MTG players love. It’s functional, looks great, and gives a much-needed boost – just like the most powerful cards in your deck.

Why We Like It

Whether you’re at the gym, in the sunny park, or at the magical table where you and your friends play card games, this non-slip Magic: The Gathering water bottle will be your perfect sidekick. And what a sidekick it is! Made of BPA-free plastic with a straw for easy drinking, it offers quality and convenience so you can fully enjoy your drink. No matter if it’s a magical potion or plain water, this bottle will keep it fresh for you.

10. Magic: The Gathering – The Best Magic: The Gathering Lanyard and Pin Set

Our Rating: 4/5 stars

What’s better than just a pin? A lanyard and pin set, of course! If you can wear these accessories at school, work, or gaming meetups, this Magic: The Gathering lanyard and pin set is what you need. And they’re not just functional – they look great, and the pin even has a unique interactive feature. I love this set, so let me tell you more about it.

Why We Like It

This Magic: The Gathering gift set includes a double-sided lanyard and a Pinfinity pin, both featuring a badass Ajani Goldmane design. You’ll love wearing the lanyard and having a blast with the pin’s app, which lets you download wallpapers, play music, and enjoy some cool animated art. If this is not awesome enough, this MTG gift set also comes in stunning art box packaging which, in my opinion, is a reason enough to get it.

Final Thoughts on the Best Magic: The Gathering Gifts

With so many amazing Magic: The Gathering gifts out there, it’s clear that there’s something special for every type of fan. Whether you go for protective gear, stylish accessories, or collectible items, the right gift can add a touch of magic to their next match or make their collection even more exciting. 

So, as you wrap up your search, think about what they love most about the game – it’ll lead you to the perfect choice. These gifts are so awesome that no matter which gift you choose, it’s sure to be magical and serve as a token of your friendship. Now all that’s left is to see the look on their face when they unwrap it!